Beware the Bendire’s

In the middle of the afternoon a few weeks ago I was sitting in the public library in Sierra Vista, Arizona–a wonderful facility, by the way–escaping the heat of the day to download my bird sound recordings, recharge my batteries, and check my email, when my attention was drawn to a bird hopping directly toward me on the ground.  No, it wasn’t in the library–it was on the other side of the floor-to-ceiling plate-glass windows, out in the desert garden.  But it might as well have been in the library, because it ended up hopping right up to the window, less than four feet from my face, so that even without binoculars I could clearly see its pale yellow eye, its short, almost straight bill, its nearly-unmarked breast with a few spots front and center…in short, every field mark necessary to confirm its identity as a Bendire’s Thrasher–a scarce species I had seen only three times before.

And then, through the window, I heard it begin to call: a slightly noisy, one-syllabled note reminiscent of the “cheep” call of the American Robin.  Naturally, I raced right out to record it:

cbthjuv4c-ndp2009-15-06

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

The call note clinched the ID.  It was completely different from the characteristic call of the very similar-looking Curve-billed Thrasher, the loud wit-weet! that is a trademark sound of the southwestern deserts:

Curve-billed Thrasher call. Catalina State Park, Arizona, 2/23/2008 (08-19).

Curve-billed Thrasher call. Catalina State Park, Arizona, 2/23/2008 (08-19).

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

I was particularly excited to record the Bendire’s because their one-syllabled call note had been described in the literature, but as far as I could tell, never recorded — I didn’t know of any commercially available recordings that included it, nor had I ever seen published spectrograms of it.  The Macaulay Library didn’t have it, and in the two different mornings I’d spent recording Bendire’s Thrasher in Arizona and California, I’d never even heard it, much less caught it on tape.  So I was pretty stoked.

I relayed the details of my sighting to my friend Andrew Spencer, who was due to arrive in southeast Arizona shortly after I returned to Colorado.  He was equally excited about this rare recording opportunity, and he made a point of stopping at the Sierra Vista Public Library as well.  That morning I got a message from him that relayed some good news and some bad news.  The good news: he’d found the bird right where I said it would be, acting just as I’d said it would, giving calls just like the ones I’d recorded.  The bad news?  It had been accompanied by, and fed by, two adult Curve-billed Thrashers.  It wasn’t a Bendire’s at all–it was just a juvenile Curve-billed.

Sure enough, when I went to look at the Bendire’s Thrasher chapter in Kenn Kaufmann’s Advanced Birding, there was the description of a juvenile Curve-billed Thrasher, matching my bird to a T.  I had forgotten that Bendire’s has a pale base to the lower mandible, which my bird had lacked.  And Kaufmann even mentions the single-syllabled call note of the juvenile Curve-billed.  Blast.

The morals of this story:

  1. Juvenile Curve-billed Thrashers look and sound far more like Bendire’s than I ever thought possible;
  2. Even the most seemingly slam-dunk IDs can be wrong;
  3. I still don’t know of a recording of the call of Bendire’s Thrasher.  Anyone?  Anyone?

5 comments to Beware the Bendire’s

  • Andrew Spencer

    Stokes has an EXCELLENT recording of BETH call. Presumably Lang Elliot’s work.

  • Andrew Spencer

    We’ve had this discussion before, btw. I even played the call for you.

  • Nathan Pieplow

    Really? I’ll be the first to admit that commercially available recordings are a huge blind spot for me. I’ll have to check that out.

  • Great site, Nathan! The content is excellent and I love the look and organization of the site. It’s great that your recordings are embedded in the same page (and with the spectrograms). I just read all of your posts to date and look forward to more.

    Hope all’s well!

    Bill

  • Leanna Shaberly

    I see a half dozen or more Bendire’s every day, at my feeders. Get in touch with me the next time you’re coming to Phoenix. I’m a half hour from the airport, depending on how long it takes to get a rental car. I 99 per cent guarantee you’ll see Bendire’s here. I’ll have to double check my thrasher video. I’m well aware of the one note call of the thrashers, that sounds like a robin. I grew up in Ohio and go back and visit from time to time. This past winter, the robin call seem so fantastically realistic I finally turned around from my cleaning in the garage , to look at it. Son of a gun – it was a robin !! Since a Rufous-backed Robin was being sighted daily a couple of hours straight east of me I looked and looked for the rufous back, but just couldn’t swing – it was just a plain old American Robin.